How to Make the Best Jello Shots That Taste Delightful -

Table of Contents

My Search for the Best Tasting Jello Shots

When was the last time you had a jello shot? If you enjoy them as I do you may be wondering how you can make the best jello shots of your own.

This post may contain affiliate links. By clicking on an affiliate link I may financially benefit at no extra cost to you.

Sweet Jello Shots

I enjoy my drinks on the sweet side, so it was no wonder these colorful little treats were a hit with me. My first time trying one was on a party bus heading to a concert.

In the beginning, when I would have a jello shot or two all I could remember was the smell of sweet flavors like cherry or lime. However, once I sucked it down it tasted like cherry rubbing alcohol.

Even though the taste wasn’t great I still reached for another. I found out later that they would use the cheapest alcohol they could find because who cared? (Well, I did!)

Creative Ways to Make Jello Shots

I think the job of a jello shot is to give you a little buzz and taste delicious and fun. When I make them I am sure to use quality ingredients for optimum taste. So with that said, I truly believe I make the best Jello Shots!

You could think that all may make me sound a little hoity-toity but really it’s just about the taste and how I want to enjoy this drinkable dessert. I would love to help you be the best jello shot maker in your crowd too!

The Best Jello Shot Ideas

When I first started making them I thought you only used vodka. I soon realized that you can use almost any alcohol but one thing to consider is that some of the spirits give off a stronger taste.

I have been collecting jello shot recipes for over 15 years. My search is always on for marvelous new tastes for everyone to enjoy. Some of them have even become a favorite with friends and family.

Silly Questions About Jello Shots (Are They Silly?)

I had a friend ask me once “How do you eat a jello shot?” She was looking for a spoon (on a party bus).

Here is what works for me when eating a jello shot. I will loosen the edges with my tongue. Then I will just slurp it down. I follow the rule to never use your fingers! (You know where those fingers have been!)

Another question I hear is “Are Jello Shots strong?” The answer for the Jello Shots that I make is yes, sort of. Mine are a little strong, but not too strong as to ruin the taste (and because if you use too much alcohol they won’t set up).

I also hear “Will Jello Shots melt?” In short, yes! I always make sure when traveling with them that they are well iced. No one wants to come back to the party bus with melted Jello Shots!

The Best Jello Shot Varieties — The Best Jello Shots

Jello Shot Tips

I will show you how I make some of my favorites and give you some tips on how to create your own tasty Jello Shots. In showing you how I make them you can always substitute your favorite brand of alcohol according to your taste and wallet.

Here are some extra tips to help you make the Best Jello Shots

When using vodka I prefer Kettle One but many people love Titos. When I use white rum I frequently use Bacardi.
I use 2-ounce jello shot cups and lids. But feel free to use what you like. However, make sure your cup size isn’t too deep. Some people have short tongues.
I put my alcohol in the freezer prior to mixing. It helps the shots set up quicker.
If you are concerned with sticking, you can take a small amount of cooking spray and place it in the bottom of the cup. Then dab it so it is barely there.
It is a great idea to make your jello shots a few days in advance as they will be good for up to 4 days after mixing when in constant refrigeration. If you are in a hurry to make them for an event the same day try placing them in the freezer after mixing. (However, I don’t like this way as my shots seem gummier).
I bring out a cookie sheet (or two) before I start. When I finish filling my shots I place them on the cookie sheet to refrigerate. This makes them easier to get in and out of the refrigerator. They are easily stackable too!
If you want to make some Jello Shots without alcohol you can substitute water or juice for the alcohol portion. I always make sure to label these special so you have no confusion

As Promised, My Favorite Recipe’s

Berry Blue Jello Shots

3-ounce package Berry Blue Jello
1 cup boiling water
¾ cup cold Vodka
¼ cup cold water

Bring water to a boil and mix in jello package until completely dissolved. Next stir in cold vodka and cold water. Pour immediately into shot cups. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours.

Kamikaze Jello Shots

3-ounce package Lime Jello
3-ounce package Lemon Jello
1 ½ cups Vodka
½ cup Triple Sec
1 cup cold Sweet and Sour mix
1 cup of cold Water

Bring vodka and triple sec to barely a boil. Stir in both jello packages until completely dissolved. Then add the cold sweet and sour mix as well as the cold water. Stir. Pour immediately into shot cups. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours.

Cherry Cuba Libre Jello Shots

3-ounce box of Cherry Jello (I prefer not to use Black Cherry)
1 cup boiling Coke
½ cup cold Coke
½ cup White Rum

Brink Coke to just barely a boil. Stir in Jello until dissolved. Next, add cold Coke and cold Rum. Pour immediately into shot cups. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours.

Fuzzy Navel Jello Shots

6-ounce package of Orange Jello
1 ½ cup boiling water
½ cup cold water
1 cup cold Peach Schnapps
1 cup cold Vodka

Bring 1 cup of water to a boil. Then mix Jello until dissolved. Next add ½ cup cold water, Peach Schnapps, and vodka, and stir until well blended. Pour immediately into shot cups. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours.

Sex On The Beach Jello Shots

3-ounce Orange Jello
1 cup boiling Cranberry Juice
3 ounces cold Peach Schnapps
5 ounces of cold Vodka

Bring Cranberry Juice to a barely boil. Next mix in Jello until dissolved. Then add cold water, Peach Schnapps, and Vodka and stir until well blended. Pour immediately into shot cups. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours.

I hope you enjoy my recipes. I would love to hear your favorites so I can try them myself! And if you have any Jello Shot questions feel free to send me a note!