Lighten Up Your Libations: Top Sugar Free Cocktail Syrups Compared -

When it comes to crafting cocktails at home, the right sugar-free cocktail syrups can make or break your drink.

Whether you’re watching your sugar intake or chasing authentic flavors, three popular brands stand out: Skinny Brand, Matteo’s, and Torani. Each brings a different vibe to your bar setup—but which one deserves that front-and-center spot in your cocktail cart?

Let’s break it down by flavor, ingredients, mixability, and more.

This post may contain affiliate links. By clicking on an affiliate link I may financially benefit at no extra cost to you.

Table of Contents

Flavor, Variety & Authenticity

Skinny Brand: Offers a large selection (over 40 flavors) of sugar-free options, including Margarita, Peach, Coconut, and Mojito. While convenient, some flavors can taste artificial, especially in more delicate cocktails.
Matteo’s Syrups: Smaller selection, but the flavors are richer and often closer to the real thing. Their Espresso and Sweet & Sour mixers are especially popular for quality home mixology.
Torani: The OG syrup brand for many home and commercial bars. With over 100 flavors, including both classic and adventurous options (48 sugar-free cocktail syrups), Torani delivers reliable taste. Their fruit flavors are great for tiki and soda-style drinks, but some find them too sweet or syrupy for refined cocktails.

Winner for Flavor Variety: Torani
Winner for Authentic Flavor: Matteo’s
Winner for Balanced Sweetness: Skinny Brand

Summer Variety Pack

Torani Sugar Free Fruit Flavor Syrup Variety Pack

Buy Now →

(This post may contain Amazon affiliate links. By clicking on an affiliate link I may financially benefit at no extra cost to you.)

Sweeteners & Health-Focused Options

Skinny Brand: Uses sucralose and other zero-calorie sweeteners. Ideal for low-carb or keto cocktails, but not ideal if you’re avoiding artificial ingredients.
Matteo’s Syrups: Often use a mix of natural sweeteners and stevia, offering a more health-conscious but still indulgent experience.
Torani: Offers both regular (with cane sugar) and sugar-free versions (using sucralose or erythritol). Their “Puremade” line avoids artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives.

Winner for All-Natural Options: Torani Puremade Line
Winner for Zero-Calorie Focus: Skinny Brand
Winner for Stevia-Based Sweeteners: Matteo’s

Margaritas without the guilt

Skinny Mixes Sugar Free Margarita Mix

Buy Now →

(This post may contain Amazon affiliate links. By clicking on an affiliate link I may financially benefit at no extra cost to you.)

Mixability & Cocktail Performance

Skinny Brand: Easy to mix with a thinner consistency. Works best in highballs, spritzers, and low-ABV cocktails. Won’t cloud drinks.
Matteo’s Syrups: Thicker, richer, and bolder—excellent for shaken or stirred classics where syrup plays a starring role.
Torani: Highly versatile. Their standard syrups are great for frozen cocktails, syrups for coffee, lemonades, sodas, or layered shots. Not always the best for elevated craft cocktails without some balance work.

Best for Craft Cocktails: Matteo’s
Best for Simple Mixes & Spritzers: Skinny Brand
Best for Versatility (from cocktails to coffee): Torani

For Your Tropical Flair

Matteo’s Sugar-Free Coconut Syrup

Buy Now →

(This post may contain Amazon affiliate links. By clicking on an affiliate link I may financially benefit at no extra cost to you.)

Price & Availability Of Sugar Free Cocktail Syrups

Skinny Brand: Affordable and widely available at big-box retailers and online. Budget-friendly for everyday use.
Matteo’s Syrups: Mid-range price, harder to find in stores but available online. More of a specialty product.
Torani: Very accessible and competitively priced. You’ll find them in grocery stores, coffee shops, and online in bulk.

Most Budget-Friendly: Skinny Brand
Most Accessible Everywhere: Torani
Best Premium Taste Value: Matteo’s

For budget-friendly bottles of all three brands, click my Amazon links from above or go to Marshall’s or TJ Maxx, which often carry selected flavors. If you’re looking for the full array of options, be sure to browse through my affiliate link for Skinny Mixes complete selection and exclusive deals.

Final Pour: Which One’s Best for You?

🥂 For health-conscious mixers on keto or calorie-counting plans → Skinny Brand
🍸 For flavor-forward cocktail lovers who want depth and authenticity → Matteo’s Syrups
🍹 For versatile home bartenders who also dabble in coffee, mocktails, and dessert drinks → Torani

All three brands can be useful tools in your home bar—just match them to the type of cocktail experience you’re after.

Do you have a favorite? We would love to hear from you!